Gear Heads | Growing Fresh Herbs with Indoor Gardens
Gear Heads | Growing Fresh Herbs with Indoor Gardens
Countertop garden systems promise to make it easy to grow fresh herbs. But do they deliver? Lisa and Hannah put them to the test.
Buy our winning Indoor Garden on Amazon: https://cooks.io/2xnKzJ6
Read the full review: https://cooks.io/2NpLSSH
ABOUT US: Located in Boston’s Seaport District in the historic Innovation and Design Building, America’s Test Kitchen features 15,000 square feet of kitchen space including multiple photography and video studios. It is the home of Cook’s Illustrated magazine and Cook’s Country magazine and is the workday destination for more than 60 test cooks, editors, and cookware specialists. Our mission is to test recipes over and over again until we understand how and why they work and until we arrive at the best version.
If you like us, follow us:
Hannah’s Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/hannah_crowley8
Lisa’s Twitter: https://twitter.com/lisamcmanus
http://americastestkitchen.com
http://facebook.com/americastestkitchen
Tweets by TestKitchen
http://instagram.com/testkitchen
http://pinterest.com/testkitchen
what the hell is harder to manage on the aerogarden vs the others??? you just feed it every 2 weeks and top up the water every once in a while. The other plants got starved for light because you didn’t prune it well
This made me to understand that you can actually grow herbs in own home
Wow!!! Thank you! I have always wondered about these
Price aside, “Dumb” setups don’t have apps harvesting your data while you try to harvest dill!
Thank you.
I would be concerned about eye damage from all these UV lights, no shielding at all from any of them.
Can you make one for a windowsill garden?
Thank YOU Americas test kitchens for doing all the work for us!!!
I love my aerogarden. You either got the wrong one or did something wrong.
My Chia Pet garden is almost a decade old, cost about $10 and so far all’s well. All I need is a tray and a window.
Yes very helpful video. Now do another one with large units
Gear Heads? Where are the cars?
Was this paid by Click & Grow? It is recommended by them to start with the low light setting and then use the extensions. You seem to paint a slightly blurry picture. And I purchased a click and grow myself as it seems the best option
Who in the world would actually use these?! 200$ for a bunch of plastic and a tiny amount of actual seeds, that you could easily get for a couple of bucks in any store.
Just plant herbs in a pot with soil and water them regularly – what’s so hard about that?! If watering a plant is already too much work for someone (how?!), just buy them all-grown in the store. You can get a lot of fresh herbs for 200$.
Seriously: Who needs an app to grow plants?! It’s not rocket-science! -_-
Just curious…was the Juice Plus Tower garden tested? If not, are there any plans to compare it to the Click n Grow
I got the Miracle Grow Bounty to have a countertop garden. I don’t know what counter that click and grow is supposed to go on. I am happy with mine.
It looks like the Click and Grow has an extra long extender compared to mine.
With the Click and Grow…can you plant and grow plants easily from seeds YOU buy, rather than buying the pre-made pre-packaged dirt/plant modules from the company?
Really like the new style of the test kitchen videos!
Great info, Thanks
Get the "Bounty" version of the Aerogarden. It is much larger and has a vertical extension rod that makes it much taller. Plus it is regularly on sale for around or just over $200. It is a lot easier and convenient than what they make it out to be. That tall white one that I think was called the "Click" has a light bar that is stationary which is bad. That is why that lettuce was floppy and spindly, the light needs to be much closer than that. I guess this the kind of review you get from people that don’t actually know a ton about it. So if you plan to get something like this without spending a fortune, buy the Aerogarden Bounty base model and it will out perform all of these and is much larger. The reason the Edn had so many issues was likely it had bad or no seed. You need to make sure the expiration date on the package is still good. Also temperature/humidity make big impacts on the viability of the seed and whether it will germinate or not. If the pods were sitting in a hot warehouse for six months or more that could have ruined the seeds in the pods.
I don’t think people are going to be growing basil and lettuce in these things 😉
Good to know, thanks!
The short ones look like they were made for going under the counter and for where you’d be clipping them all the time
The more you clip the better the plant grows
The winner looks like it’d need its own room or house
I own an aerogarden and know that it is the best at growing hydroponic plants. Sorry ladies, you still have to trim and take care of your plants.
That one lady sounds like she’s not going to be happy until everything’s robotic and no human involved whatsoever
She always says
"I had to do this"
I had to do that ((grumph))
Like oh my God I can’t believe I had to look at this thing then I had to touch it cut off the clippings
Where are the robots
OMG, why was I born before there were robots
Who’s fault is this
So, I’m going to keep my tray and clip on led set up ($45, total)? Cool.
Just stick to cooking, PLEASE.
Once again Americas test kitchen comes to my rescue! I should just search you guys any time I need to get anything. I’m still loving the ninja smoothie blender I bought because of your review
finally, actually content outside of Dan’s
I have both Click and Grow and Aerogarden. Couldn’t agree more with this review. While I love both of them, Click and Grow is a lot simpler and it also just looks more aesthetically pleasing
My, I’m pushing the back button so much, to bypass the commercials I’m missing this site, with the Ads they are trying to show on each video. So Sad. they are doing this. Had enough of the solar panel.
but can you grow devil’s lettuce
I would love to have a pint or two with both wonderful ladies and talk about kitchen gadgets! Best regards to both of you!
In my younger College days I used to grow beautiful weed plants with just a clip on desk lamp with a daylight CFL bulb in my bedroom closet so I’m sure basil wouldn’t be that hard.
Amazing video! Thank you! 🙂
Thank you for featuring Lisa McManus. She is the reason why I subscribed to your channel. Her videos are always so thorough and informative.
I have an AeroGarden Harvest, and it’s amazing – easy (no app needed), and great yield. The only thing that grows tall is the basil; everything else gets along nicely. Their cherry tomatoes are yummy & the plants are quite hardy. IDK why this unit seemed difficult to you – maybe the app made it harder?
The Click & Grow looks nice, but it’s huge! both its footprint and clearance for height.
FYI for some other commenters: There are ways to reduce the amount of plastic waste when you use these systems, which is another plus. 🙂
Interesting that the products were the same price but wildly different results
I just want to keep one basil plant alive. Other people can do it. Why can’t I?
$200？ I think I’ll just buy fresh herbs when needed.
The winner is so wasteful! Plastic that can’t be truely recycled, instructions that are only available with an unrecyclable cellphone, soil and fertilizer that we know nothing about in terms of soil health. This is a half-baked (pun intended) test with no conscience about the world and it’s affect on the world. There are fairly easy ways to grow indoor (if need be) herbs and lettuce grown indoors doesn’t have any taste (readily available hydroponic bibb lettuce anyone?)
Over all this leaves me heaving.
Hey Lisa, ❤️ thanks for what y’all do. I’ve been wanting to plant an herb garden.
My problem with most indoor garden systems is you have to have a fair amount of usable real estate to have them, no matter how ‘compact’ they claim. You lose cubic footage from the table, shelf or counter, and you lose an outlet.
These systems are way too expensive and you need their pods (except the one that didn’t perform well). It is much cheaper to buy a heavy duty shelf, grow lights and hooks.
That lettuce looks so pale and leggy. Either you didn’t start the light off lower (it _does_ have an adjustable height) or the roots have broken through the wick and aren’t drawing enough nutrients from the ‘pods’. I’ve grown the same lettuce in the same ‘garden’ and it was a lot bushier and more of a vibrant green.
What about aero garden?
what if I don’t have a smart phone?
Younger generations are gonna starve… especially after their phones die…
More at home gardening vids please! Also discuss which types of plants are best for in home